10 Things You Want To Know From an Art Director

Want a better chance of getting hired? Read this:

There are raging debates online all over the place about how to approach Art Directors and Creative Directors to show work. Email them, or don’t. Do backflips for them, send them a carrier pigeon, only send a book, etc. Frankly, it’s all over the damned map. As it turns out, some of those folks are my friends and they want to help us help them. And they aren’t afraid to share their opinion. So here’s 10 questions (pulled from yours and updated with a few of mine) that needed answering following my chasejarvisLIVE a couple weeks back with AD/Brand Manager Jason Sutherland. Here, Jason goes deeper.

Thanks for spending some time with us here, Jason. Give us the truth, how do you prefer to be approached by new photographers?

Ideally, with a drink in their hand. Second to that, I like to be approached by photographers gently. In that they know me, they know what I’m trying to do, and they show me a carefully selected range of images that blinds me with their brilliance. Then they wow me with their genuine niceness and my vision is magically repaired.  This can be accomplished online, or via the old school mail, or…… at a nice bbq. Also, I read mailers, I flip through clever books, I peruse websites, and I go down odd rabbit holes in the internets and come back up with interesting things. I’ve said this before, but I’m always out there looking. I love great images, art, music, and works that weave it all together. If you’re doing cool stuff, I can’t wait to discover it.

And if I reach out to you, respond with a prompt, professional, friendly response. If you’re too busy at the time, or don’t think it’d be a good partnership, feel free to tell me that. That helps me know who is interested, and who is just stringing me along because they feel like they have to say yes to every job they get. I want to work with passionate, driven individuals who want to join me in my quest to get as many people outdoors as possible. If shooting conceptual fashion is your love, maybe I know somebody looking for that. If I do, and you’re good at it, I’ll hook you up.

The reality is that I’m not always going to have work for people. Within REI I work on an annual budget cycle, and sometimes I’m planning things out even longer than that. Patience and polite tenacity are good traits to have as a photographer who want to work with larger clients. Often times the biggest determiner of future success for somebody is how they handle rejection. If somebody is graceful, understanding, humble and positive, that ranks high in my book and they’re definitely somebody I’ll keep in mind for future projects. Somebody who is pissed because a job didn’t fall into their lap probably will have equally drama-ridden sets. No thanks. Play chess, people, not checkers.

When trying to get work from commercial or other clients, do you think it’s a good idea to invest your work into a small book to send to the particular clients I’m trying to get work from or just send them a link to my online portfolio with say an email.

In my opinion, if you send a tailored book that resonates with what the particular client is trying to do it’ll be more effective that just an email with a link to your portfolio. It demonstrates a higher level of investment and commitment, and it’ll stick around longer than an email. The key is to ensure it’s relevant to the particular client. We very much enjoy seeing great new work, and when good stuff comes in it’s widely shared among the art director posse.

Do you get your physical book back when you send it to a potential client? Or is it an operating cost?

I always try to return people’s books to them. Not so with something that is obviously promotional materials, but a portfolio sent to me on a specific request is definitely coming back to you. That’s just respect. Unsolicited materials won’t make it back to you, but if it’s good I’m going to share your work with other art directors.

Although now that I look around my workspace, I’m feeling pangs of guilt because I see a few books here that somebody probably wants back. Especially this really nicely bound set of booklet things in a sleeve from guy named Kyle RM Johnson. Nice stuff buddy.

This comes as a horror to some, and a boondoggle to others: How do you view companies using user-submitted photography versus professionally produced photography?

View these companies like your best buddy. REI uses user-submitted photography, and we’ve learned a lot about what it does and doesn’t do for us. Here’s what it does for us: It brings our customer’s voice to the work we do, and for us as a member-owned co-op that’s really important. It also brings a natural diversity in terms of age, ethnicity, geography, ability level and many more dimensions that we could never authentically cover in our shot-for photography. But I’ve gotta be honest – it rarely inspires people at the level that a beautifully done professional piece of photography can. Nobody is sending us pics of snowboarders at the level of Marni Yamada arcing a sick line across a field of fresh with a rooster tail of chunks trailing behind. And yet these are the shots we gather around when they’re on our screens, gazing with silly grins on our faces. Trust me, there’s a beautiful, much-appreciated place for professional photographers creating amazing images.

There’s also a lesson wrapped within this answer that I feel I need to call out. Think about it – if the reason I like customer-supplied imagery is because it’s authentic and real, it probably opens up some doors for people who are creating super-inspirational images in an authentic manner. This affects your choice of locations, talent, as well as how you capture the image. Yes, it demands more of you, but I think I also just showed you a peek at a niche that’ll make you ridiculously in demand. Dope imagery + uber authenticity = employment, job satisfaction, happiness, whiter teeth, and the ability to leap tall buildings in a single bound.

Is keeping ones age a secret important?

Hello, my name is Jason and I am forty-one years old. And next year, if I’m lucky and nothing huge (like a barn, for example) falls out of the sky and crushes me, I’ll be a year older.

In other words, no. Sure my age might put me on one side or the other of somebody’s artificial divide, but I’m thinking I don’t want to work for somebody who judges me by my age. Especially when there are so many better things to judge me by, such as the car I drive, the music I listen to, or my awesome zebra-striped parachute pants. The people I want to work with are looking at my work and my attitude. My age is happenstance, just an accumulated ball of stories, wisdom, folly and failure.

Do you find it rewarding working as CD under the roof of one brand? What tactics or guiding light principals do you and the gang put in place to “keep it fresh”?

Yes, very rewarding. What’s cool about working with one brand is you get to know it well. And in the case of REI there are many overlaps in the brand values with my own personally held values, so it’s a great thing.

As far as keeping it fresh, I’d have to say the biggest thing that keeps it fresh is how the market and our customers are evolving. The things we’re doing today with social media are using parts of our brain that five years ago we didn’t even know we had. The directness of the conversation with your customers, and the real-time feedback you get from them drives the work in new directions and keeps it interesting. If I were just making catalogs filled with pictures of people wearing clothes I would’ve quit a long time ago. Sure we still make catalogs, but it’s a fairly small part of a continuous stream of communication and interaction with our customers on many levels.

It’s pretty exciting times on a macro level to be in marketing. There are fundamental changes that are removing the falseness and duplicity that used to be the foundation of marketing. It’s gratifying, exciting and enjoyable to sledgehammer that stuff down. That fires me up as much as anything.

On a micro level, I have a few creative principles that I use as my guide for my crew and myself. They’re pretty straight-forward:

1.     Tell stories.
2.     Use real people in real places.
3.     Be refreshingly direct.
4.     Root it all in authenticity.

That’s pretty much it. It’s sort of the new-school marketing manifesto – no bs. We don’t hit these all the time, but they’re what we’re striving for. Beyond that, we have brand standards and a defined visual language at REI. The brand standards and definition were created in-house, and it was a really fun, defining project. REI now has a very focused brand definition, and it’s used throughout the company to anchor and focus our efforts. REI has used (and currently uses) agencies to help develop new campaigns, and the work the customer sees is a collaboration between the agency and the in-house team. REI has a very good in-house posse. I can only speak for myself, but I have a lot of fun working with the crew, and it’s the crackling of all those brains and synapses that makes it interesting.

Could you tell us about some of your most difficult experiences working with clients / A.D.s / C.D.s, what you learned from those experiences and the best way not to get into those situations in the first place.

On frustrating shoots where you’re not getting what you want, or when things seem to be blowing up on you, it usually comes down to poor communication. Maybe the planning isn’t solid and nobody knows what the they’re trying to shoot. Maybe there are too many people on the shoot with and opinion of what they’re trying to shoot, and the photographer is being fed conflicting directions. Maybe the talent is half as talented as they said they were, and are unable to do the task in front of them. All of these things can create friction and frustration on the set, and I’ve been on shoots where these have all happened.

No matter what’s causing the friction, this is the moment to step forward and work things out very directly, honestly and firmly. This should be a conversation between the AD, the photographer and the producer. I’ve been very fortunate to work with great crews, and have developed a good bond of trust with those people so that when bad things happen, it’s an easier conversation and we quickly, considerately and thoughtfully get to a solution.

As the photographer, you need to take this leadership role, and make the call. And when you do step into that conversation, make sure you’re ears are open and you’re listening. Then offer your brilliant insight, and if possible, an equally brilliant solution.

How not to get into these bad situations? Trust your instincts. If things seem disorganized, unfocused or just plain f-d up before you head out on the shoot, things usually only get worse when you’re on a set, money is burning, and the pressure goes up. Things happen on shoots that cause stress. You need to be in a place of good balance so that when they happen it’s just a thing that happened, not an excuse for all hell to break loose.

Which means it’s up to you to set the tone. Be positive and solution oriented. One of the things I enjoy about working with Chase is that he takes things seriously, but not too seriously. I remember one shoot where he kicked it off with a nice tone setting speech. I’m paraphrasing, but he basically said that we’re all here to get a job done and we want to do it really well, but this isn’t brain surgery or rescue work so let’s keep it fun along the way. Then he asked for everybody to keep an eye out for how they could be helpful and pitch in if help was needed. Things tend to go right when that’s your ethos.

How do you decide to extend a shoot and how do you cover those costs. Do you discuss with the photographer?

We (the producer, the photographer and the art director) are constantly monitoring the shoot as it moves along through the schedule with an eye toward any unforeseen changes that might cause mayhem with our plans. REI’s shoots are very weather dependent, so we’re prepared with a few contingency plans based on fairly extensive experience. Often on big shoots there’s an “extra” day built into the schedule, or at the very least the order of the days can be moved around to accommodate different scenarios. If it looks like an extra day is essential due to weather, the bulk of the cost is on our bill. We all grimace a bit, because in addition to the cost, we know that a change like an extra day has a ripple effect on people’s lives. Many of our crew move on to other jobs, and down time between shoots can be precious.

What is your personal creative manifesto? Lloyd Wright, Tolstoy, and many others had their own manifestos, but what is yours?

Uh, mine’s not gonna sound very positive, but it actually is. Here goes:

F it all and f-n no regrets. (Not the gentrified sounds of St. Anger, I’m talking Master of Puppets here.) Bottom line, get pissed, destroy. And by destroy, I mean tear it all down so you create something new and wonderful out of the strange parts that are left over. Make stuff. Cool stuff. Move on. Make more. Don’t dwell in the past. (It’s over.)

I can restate this manifesto in terms of unicorns, phoenixes and a little talking kitten that believed he could be somebody, but I respect y’all too much to do that.

And here’s a bonus over-all point coming straight from my heart to your brain:

One of the best things you can do to develop yourself as a photographer, art director or creative person is to play a different role than what you usually do. If you’re always behind the camera, get in front of it. Be a model. You’ll quickly learn more about what it takes to give good direction than you thought possible. If you’re an art director, pick up a camera and shoot some pictures or make a film (the shiny part goes toward the subject). Shoot some shots that technically and artistically challenge you, try and tell a story that’s in your heart, and you’ll have a much greater appreciation for what it takes to deliver a creative vision by using a machine. Plus, the more you learn about photography the less you’ll be the person asking for the impossible.

I’m not suggesting mixing it up on a big-dollar shoot, because everybody will think you’re wacky and you’ll probably get fired. But definitely do it on your own time. Create a project just for the sake of learning something new. It’s an amazing way to understand very clearly what it takes to make a successful shoot. I’ve pursued gigs that made me cringe because they were way out of my comfort zone (“uh, you want me to stand where…?”) but I did it anyway because I knew that it’d push me to learn new stuff. And the experience gave me greater empathy when I was back in my usual zone of bossiness.

That’s all for now. Go do cool stuff.

[Thanks Jason. Follow up questions have a good chance of getting answered in the comments. Follow Jason on twitter here and check out his blog here.]

You may be interested in:

33 Responses to 10 Things You Want To Know From an Art Director

  1. J Sandifer April 22, 2011 at 11:33 am #

    Excellent post…I think too often creatives get so caught up in what they are doing they forget to think about those that can make or break their business. The point of knowing the product and actually spending time to understand what the CD is looking for should not be taken lightly…and try to understand how they want to receive images before sending. I was talking to an editor on Wed night and she loves contact sheets still, so sending her a disc of images might not even get your work seen.

    One question that I would be interested in hearing Jason answer is…is his budget increasing this year over last years? The people I am speaking with are starting to put a slightly positive spin on spending and feel like things are slowly coming back!

  2. ken April 22, 2011 at 12:56 pm #

    Thanks for the insight Jason.
    Not sure if you’d do this if there are trade secrets behind it, but I’d love to hear what goes on behind the scenes of what happens *before* the shooting of an REI “campaign”. I.e., what is the thought process. I’m sure it’s not something pulled out of thin air like, “hey, let’s send Chase out to Patagonia for some cool shots”. I’d like to hear more of “our assignment for the spring REI catalog was…” and then how you did the concept, scheduling, finding photographers, etc.
    Thanks to Chase for interviewing you too. I don’t know any ADs so this gives me a lot of insight into a side of marketing I’d never have exposure to :-)

  3. amber snow April 22, 2011 at 1:35 pm #

    As someone who is in the beginning stages of even just hoping to get into the commercial photography industry, this article is quite inspiring. Thank you for posting it.

  4. Micah Kvidt April 22, 2011 at 1:58 pm #

    Another great post, Chase! Thanks!

  5. Matt Timmons April 22, 2011 at 3:30 pm #

    Cheers Jason,
    I never would have figured you for a Damage Inc. guy, but I’m glad to see that the headbanger in you can still have a sacred place in your persona while you strive forward professionally. I’m a common thread- the guy on the fashion shoot set pursuing high class and prestige in my images while keeping the Leper Messiah attitude into my creative approach- don’t follow rules, follow vision. This was a good read, man. Thanks for the insight and thoroughness.

    Matt

  6. Dan Kaufman April 22, 2011 at 6:19 pm #

    very insightful and very much common sense. do unto others as you would have them do unto you.

    thank you both for sharing so generously.

    Dan Kaufman

  7. Venura Herath April 22, 2011 at 8:31 pm #

    Very inspiring! Thanks Chase & Jason!

  8. DejanD April 23, 2011 at 4:18 am #

    Absolutely inspiring. Thanks Chase and Jason for sharing this.

  9. Raman SIngh April 23, 2011 at 4:18 am #

    Another awsome post post. Thanks Chase!… Thanks Jason!

  10. fas April 23, 2011 at 6:01 am #

    Awesome insights. There is more than that meets the eye. It always is interesting to know how you perceive some of those questions. Could vary from person to person IMO.

  11. Michael Montalto April 24, 2011 at 7:19 pm #

    Doens’t listening/watching anything from Chase just make you want to give back at all times? Never in my life in 12 years of business have I ever come anywhere close to the amount of information sharing that I’ve found in the creative community (as a comparison). There are no free lunches..that much stays the same. That being said however, the insistance that we all grow forces a dynamic that is something radical and to be extremely proud of.

    Cheers,

    mM

  12. Valgas Moore April 25, 2011 at 1:44 pm #

    You’re awesome, Chase.

  13. Sanjay Ringh April 26, 2011 at 11:09 am #

    “F it all and f-n no regrets. (Not the gentrified sounds of St. Anger, I’m talking Master of Puppets here.) Bottom line, get pissed, destroy. And by destroy, I mean tear it all down so you create something new and wonderful out of the strange parts that are left over. Make stuff. Cool stuff. Move on. Make more. Don’t dwell in the past. (It’s over.)”

    Ah, so THAT’S why REI’s style has been so stale for the past 25 years…

    • Chase April 26, 2011 at 12:28 pm #

      @sanjay – i welcome critical opinions, but I couldn’t help but notice by your mail server info that hits my inbox with every comment that you work at REI competitor, cascade designs, and that here and every time REI is mentioned on my blog, you send a bash-y comment about them (or me).

      in the future, skip the bunk cheap shots – they reflect poorly on not just you, but on cascade designs too. i’m friends with the founders and a bunch of boss types there and i’m pretty sure that’s not on par with how they’d want you to roll.

      oh, and more importantly, that’s not what this forum is for, either.

      • jwnomad April 29, 2011 at 10:03 pm #

        And here I was thinking Sanjay was being sarcastic! LMAO

  14. digi dave April 29, 2011 at 3:46 pm #

    Like this post alot, great info.

  15. Peter Gosling May 11, 2011 at 3:25 pm #

    Aboslute gold dust for people starting out and need as many insights in to the business as possible – once again Chase, you deliver!

    thanks.

    pete

  16. Dave Bradley August 24, 2011 at 10:49 am #

    Love the post. It helps to hear a voice from”the other side. And I like the drink a BBQ part. I’m more than happy to handle that.

  17. prince kojo-hilton February 27, 2012 at 5:14 pm #

    i am an Artist from Ghana i most of the time works as set designer an Art director now advancing to the production designer level, i need guidance pls help me view my projects and documentaries on youtube by longing in my name Prince kojo-hilton and on facebook as well thank you,

  18. Geoffrey Shirilla December 22, 2012 at 12:51 am #

    Thank you for sharing some of the info.

  19. Stacey Wais January 5, 2013 at 10:29 am #

    It’s laborious to find on the ball ancestors resting on this subject, then again you sound approximating you understand what you’re speaking about! Thanks

  20. Albert Leadman January 6, 2013 at 8:50 am #

    very best trade Preteen Cp If I didn’t have to worry about STDs and pregnancy, this would fulfill each sexual desire I always had … nevertheless I don’t get Spanish, the moaning is terrible (THEY SOUND LIKE GHOSTS Popular A GRAVEYARD) … except used for the authentic record visuals itself … it is super, super hawt. Yeah, I don’t get in relation to this one…

  21. lose weight clinics January 15, 2013 at 2:46 pm #

    Very interesting topic, thanks for posting.

  22. Tim Roper May 4, 2014 at 12:50 pm #

    Another awesomely inspiring interview.

    I have a question about whether these days, it can work to mix totally “real” photos in with produced work into one portfolio. In my case, it’s produced fashion shoots and street style fashion. But I can see photographers in other areas wondering about it, too. On the one hand, it seems like it could be seen as passing the street photos off as something they’re not. But on the other, it can show how you really work, and it’s so popular now anyway. Thanks!

  23. Sharry Dawson September 1, 2014 at 10:52 am #

    Great insights, I would almost argue that the last step (to really hit this one out of the park) would be to talk to someone 1-1 to really get the low down. My friend did this with Mahmoud Zahar – who has worked for Egyptian, Turkish and American Advertising companies. You can contact with him here: https://www.wisewords.co/experiences/1181/

  24. External battery iphone5s September 16, 2014 at 12:13 am #

    Thats some nice stuff?

  25. dog training kindle books free October 30, 2014 at 9:42 am #

    Pretty! This was a really wonderful article.
    Thanks for supplying this information.

  26. myntra discount coupons November 16, 2014 at 3:03 am #

    the difficulties one has brought up in this post iw worth considering. I understand your time and effort.

  27. Couponraja November 16, 2014 at 3:04 am #

    the difficulties one has elevated in this posting iw worth taking into consideration. I get pleasure from your efforts.

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Getting your work out there. | F-Stop Drop and Roll - April 22, 2011

    [...] 10 Things You Want To Know From An Art Director. [...]

  2. Ben Pigao Photography » Interview with an Art Director - April 26, 2011

    [...] a quote from Chase Jarvis’ interview with AD/Brand Manager Jason Sutherland. On a micro level, I have a few creative principles that I use as my guide for my crew and myself. [...]

  3. The Rock Warrior Way applied to Arts and Startups | Max Riché - Blog - June 7, 2014

    [...] Jarvis discusses this aspect in an amazing manner with REI creative Brand Directir Jason Suterland here, where they dub it [...]

  4. Webcam Interview Questions for a Film Art Director | Video Recruiting Pro - October 15, 2014

    [...] Questions were found here and here. [...]

Leave a Reply

Highslide for Wordpress Plugin